| Platinum | Malone's Bar and Grill |
| Gold | Granite City Food & Brewery |
| Silver | Broadway Pizza |
| Bronze | Dehn's Country Manor |
| Top Pick | Angeno's Pizza & Pasta |
| Top Pick | Brick & Bourbon |
| Top Pick | Frankie's Chicago Style Pizza |
| Top Pick | Maple Tavern |
| Top Pick | Nadia Cakes |
| Top Pick | Pittsburgh Blue |